An insured cancels her commercial property policy mid-term at her own request. The insurer calculates the refund using the short-rate cancellation method. Compared to a pro rata cancellation, the insured will receive:
Correct
The answer is B: A smaller refund, since the insurer keeps a penalty
Short-rate cancellation applies when the insured initiates cancellation. The insurer retains a larger portion of the premium as a penalty for early cancellation, resulting in a smaller refund to the insured. Pro rata cancellation, which applies when the insurer initiates the cancellation, returns the exact proportional unearned premium with no penalty. Short-rate cancellation compensates the insurer for the administrative costs of issuing and then canceling a policy. In Texas, personal auto and residential property policies can no longer use short rate: since September 1, 2026, their unearned premium must be refunded pro rata whoever cancels, although a filed minimum retained premium is still allowed (28 TAC §5.7015).
Why not ?
Reviewed in our October 2026 Texas fact-check.
Show the answer
The answer is B: A smaller refund, since the insurer keeps a penalty
Short-rate cancellation applies when the insured initiates cancellation. The insurer retains a larger portion of the premium as a penalty for early cancellation, resulting in a smaller refund to the insured. Pro rata cancellation, which applies when the insurer initiates the cancellation, returns the exact proportional unearned premium with no penalty. Short-rate cancellation compensates the insurer for the administrative costs of issuing and then canceling a policy. In Texas, personal auto and residential property policies can no longer use short rate: since September 1, 2026, their unearned premium must be refunded pro rata whoever cancels, although a filed minimum retained premium is still allowed (28 TAC §5.7015).
Reviewed in our October 2026 Texas fact-check.